Magic Fountain
Ice cream shop Café Restaurant
Homemade ice cream store located in Mattituck, NY on the north fork of Long Island. Come check out our unique flavors & custom cakes!
Over the four decades that we’ve been around, we’ve become known for a lot of things. Some people know us as their local ice cream shop or as the shop they go to when they’re vacationing in the North Fork. Others know us for the creative flavors we serve -- everything from sweet corn and lavender to our ever-popular pumpkin. Read more
Reviews
Updates (5)
Review Magic Fountain
Loading comments-box...
John P. 2016-05-28The best ice cream shop on Long Island. They have an amazing selection of delicious flavors but when I go I have to have the English Butter Toffee.
Kelly G. 2014-06-17Their ice cream is amazing! Much of it is homemade and they always have new and interesting flavors. My favorite place for ice cream :-)
Paul D. 2017-09-25Delightfully friendly staff scoop equally delightful homemade ice cream flavors to satisfy traditionalists and adventurists alike... Best on Long...
Violet L. 2017-09-11Magic Fountain is an absolutely terrific handmade ice cream shop. I stopped here with my husband and son on the way back from the Hamptons and was...
Celsa V. 2017-09-05The most delicious ice cream I've ever had. The rainbow cookie and red velvet are heaven.
Cathy S. 2017-09-04Best ice cream on the east end!! Love all the unusual flavors, very creative, so much more than the average ice cream shop!!
Ronni Buckwald M. 2017-09-01OMG, the best ice cream ever. All homemade, all different flavors.
Stan R. 2017-08-18Two things: You've tried the rest, now try the best.
JD F. 2017-08-08Goat cheese and beets !!!!! Works for me !!!!!!!!!
Lucia C. 2017-07-10I love this place but when we went yesterday, the girl that helped us gave us smaller scoops than the rest of the others. My husband and I didn't say...
Maureen S. 2017-07-06Love love love that you have no sugar added and not just one flavor!!!
Gary S. 2017-07-01Best ice cream on Long Island. Rainbow Cookie:) Go!
Danny S. 2017-06-21love this ice cream shop. Amazing flavors, some you wouldn't expect to see in a Best flavor I like is
Jennifer W. 2017-01-15We have been coming here for years and it never disappoints. They have the biggest selection of the most delicious ice cream
Jenna R. 2016-12-10Thank you guys for brining back chocolate pb chunk again--my favorite :) Each visit is always great!
Rich C. 2016-11-07Always amazing! delicious new flavors!!! I just had the avocado and coconut!!
Don E. 2016-11-07Great ice cream. The best in east end for sure. Be prepared for long lines in summer. But worth it
Rob G. 2016-10-31GREAT ice cream and service. Highly recommended!!!
Julie F. 2016-10-11First time here and was very excited by all the amazing flavors, couldn't decide so we took home 7 different pints! Loved the rainbow cookie! The...
Barbara Prince T. 2016-10-06The YUMMIEST!! Travel there every chance we get. No trip out East is complete without a stop at Magic Fountain!
Updates from Magic Fountain
Magic Fountain L. 2015-08-30
You are all I long for, all I worship and adore.
You are all I long for, all I worship and adore.
Magic Fountain L. 2015-08-27
Local business: it's what makes our city different.
Local business: it's what makes our city different.
Magic Fountain L. 2015-08-25
Baklava ice cream
Baklava ice cream
Magic Fountain L. 2015-08-25
Red Velvet Cake ice Cream
Red Velvet Cake ice Cream
Magic Fountain L. 2015-08-20
Audi A. paid Yelp a visit and paid us a compliment! Thanks, Audi A.! Take a look at this: http://yelp.com/biz/7MZqeabmiuyIA7KBhhcGQA#hrid:Utgv_iKzopCt-GlL_eR5Uw
Audi A. paid Yelp a visit and paid us a compliment! Thanks, Audi A.! Take a look at this: http://yelp.com/biz/7MZqeabmiuyIA7KBhhcGQA#hrid:Utgv_iKzopCt-GlL_eR5Uw
Popularity of Magic Fountain
Social Media Popularity Score: This value is based on the number of visitors, checkins, and likes on Facebook in the last few months.
Most activity in November:
Magic Fountain has a total of 6685 visitors (checkins) and 3973 likes.
20 reviews of Magic Fountain.
Average grade
5
av 5.
Snowflake Ice Cream Shoppe
Sip n Soda